The original melon rating community — rate, upload and compare.
NSFW SFW

ForumRateMyMelons.comSite Help and InformationNasty Comment!

Welcome, guest Login / Sign up
Page 2 of 2 Log in to post
› Nasty Comment! 14,079 views
Member No.: 9990 View profile Log in to message
B Cup
Member No.: 9990 Posts: 249 Joined: 08/2005
▫ Oct 21 2005, 17:58 Post #21
I am looking forward to the BBW posts. The softer appearance is a much bigger turn on that the skinny rib cage look...not that there is anything wrong with that, but the current Calista Flockhart trend just isn't my cup of tea.

CMan thanks for starting what to me sounds like a damn fine idea!! :thumbup:
Member No.: 11103 View profile Log in to message
B Cup
Member No.: 11103 Posts: 356 Joined: 10/2005
▫ Oct 21 2005, 18:59 Post #22
I agree with all of you I like something to hold onto when I'm with a women.
Member No.: 10581 View profile Log in to message
C Cup
Member No.: 10581 Posts: 620 Joined: 09/2005
▫ Oct 22 2005, 01:08 Post #23
QUOTE(BusterHymen)
I do not have a problem at all with that weight.  :2thumbsup:   .. I am just curious when your talking about a BBW category would it go by weight, height, etc. just curious of how someone submitting the pic would know where to place the pic. (meaning in the BBW category or another one).


I think the girl will know if shes a BBW
Member No.: 11103 View profile Log in to message
B Cup
Member No.: 11103 Posts: 356 Joined: 10/2005
▫ Oct 22 2005, 01:10 Post #24
QUOTE(amberis1985)
I think the girl will know if shes a BBW

you are right a girl knows better then us guys.
Member No.: 10581 View profile Log in to message
C Cup
Member No.: 10581 Posts: 620 Joined: 09/2005
▫ Oct 22 2005, 01:12 Post #25
and i would also feel more comfortable posting in a BBW section.
Member No.: 5983 View profile Log in to message
C Cup
Member No.: 5983 Posts: 573 Joined: 03/2005
▫ Oct 23 2005, 15:28 Post #26
there's a couple problems making a BBW section.

#1 that means that if a girl submit pics and it's not submitted to the BBW section, I have to play god with her ego and decide if I shove her in the BBW section.... and there's no clear way to say "if a girl weighs X# of pounds she goes in the BBW sectioN" since obviously I can't judge that from a tittie pic. There are girls I would consider a little "thick" and that same girl another guy would say is a BBW and vice versa.

#2 That section would be a magnet for people putting in nasty comments.

#3 This would require programming.

#4 I might do it despite all these reasons

#5 it might not be necessary once (if it's ever done) the new script is done testing cause you girls can moderate your own comments.
Member No.: 11103 View profile Log in to message
B Cup
Member No.: 11103 Posts: 356 Joined: 10/2005
▫ Oct 23 2005, 16:52 Post #27
QUOTE(johnfreak)
there's a couple problems making a BBW section.

#1 that means that if a girl submit pics and it's not submitted to the BBW section, I have to play god with her ego and decide if I shove her in the BBW section.... and there's no clear way to say "if a girl weighs X# of pounds she goes in the BBW sectioN" since obviously I can't judge that from a tittie pic.  There are girls I would consider a little "thick" and that same girl another guy would say is a BBW and vice versa.

#2 That section would be a magnet for people putting in nasty comments.

#3  This would require programming.

#4 I might do it despite all these reasons

#5 it might not be necessary once (if it's ever done) the new script is done testing cause you girls can moderate your own comments.

Hi john could'nt you add a choise for them to pic from bbw or the main page when they submit there pics?
Member No.: 11118 View profile Log in to message
B Cup
Member No.: 11118 Posts: 103 Joined: 10/2005
▫ Oct 24 2005, 14:11 Post #28
I would judge BBW status on dress size. I know it's not completely scientific, but ladies of, say, size 16 and upwards? Maybe a poll is in order.

And I would cheer a BBW section. They're the way forward, and there are some truly lovely examples on this board :)
Member No.: 9510 View profile Log in to message
A Cup
Member No.: 9510 Posts: 20 Joined: 07/2005
▫ Oct 24 2005, 19:12 Post #29
It's really hard to put a 'limit' on what is BBW/SSBBW and what isn't.

Using Weight and/or dress size isn't necessarily the best way, eg, 170lb at 5' may be considered BBW, but not for someone who's 6'5", same with dress sizes really.

Also, what someone may consider 'normal' other people (who only like the skinny rake look for example) will view as being BBW.

Again, i don't think you can really necessarily say that the girl will know/view themself as, on quite a few BBW sites you'll see girls that probably wouldn't be considered as BBW by most people, but they probably had a SO and/or family who make them feel 'bigger' so they view themselves as being BBW.

It's a hard category to define really as it mostly depends on the individual's likes and dislikes, although there maybe some women for whom the category most definitely applys, there are also quite a number who consider themselves as BBW (but probably are just 'normal' in the view point of many people)) and just as many who perhaps should define themselves as BBW (in the eyes of others) but who see themselves as 'normal'.

IMO, it's up to the individual's themselves as to how they want to view themselves, but it's difficult to define the parameters as what makes what in order to make it a formal grouping, without taking into account things like height and so on.

edit ps: oh, and I most definitely consider myself in the BBW category, but you're only going to see close up Booby shots here to minimise the 'nasty' comments, which I'm happy to ignore personally, but I don't think they should be up to discourage others. Especially as all a rude/nasty comment does is show how narrow-minded/small-minded and prejudiced the note leaver usually is. Nobody expects everyone to like what they see, we all have different preferences, but there's no need to be rude and nasty about someone just because they aren't what you like personally.
Member No.: 11118 View profile Log in to message
B Cup
Member No.: 11118 Posts: 103 Joined: 10/2005
▫ Oct 24 2005, 19:57 Post #30
Well exactly. In all honesty, slim women just aren't my cup of tea. But I don't leave them comments telling them to down the pies and put some weight on.

You're absolutely right, some people are just narrow minded. It's all about different strokes for different folks. The world would be boring if we all liked the same things. What floats my boat doesn't do it for the guy next to me, but that's cool cos it means we can sit down and discuss what makes for the perfect woman :D

At the end of the day, all women are beautiful in one way or another. If certain people can't see that, then it's their loss isn't it :D
Member No.: 2479 View profile Log in to message
Double D's
Member No.: 2479 Posts: 3,556 Joined: 03/2005
▫ Oct 28 2005, 16:08 Post #31
QUOTE(johnfreak)
there's a couple problems making a BBW section.

#1 that means that if a girl submit pics and it's not submitted to the BBW section, I have to play god with her ego and decide if I shove her in the BBW section.... and there's no clear way to say "if a girl weighs X# of pounds she goes in the BBW sectioN" since obviously I can't judge that from a tittie pic.  There are girls I would consider a little "thick" and that same girl another guy would say is a BBW and vice versa.

#2 That section would be a magnet for people putting in nasty comments.

#3  This would require programming.

#4 I might do it despite all these reasons

#5 it might not be necessary once (if it's ever done) the new script is done testing cause you girls can moderate your own comments.


cool :) but i just started the thread cause i like a little somethin somethin extra ;)

and cool for #5 :2thumbsup:
Member No.: 11103 View profile Log in to message
B Cup
Member No.: 11103 Posts: 356 Joined: 10/2005
▫ Oct 29 2005, 13:24 Post #32
Hey cman and a good thread it is :2thumbsup: :2thumbsup: :2thumbsup:

Please log in to reply.